Squats Hurt Your Knees? What to Do Instead
The squat is often called the king of leg exercises, but it is not the only way to train your legs. If squats bother your knees, you have plenty of other options, and no single exercise is required.
First, a word about pain
Discomfort from working hard is normal. Sharp pain, or pain in the joint itself, is a signal to stop and change the exercise. If a knee has been painful for a while, or you have been told you have a joint condition, check with your doctor or a physical therapist about what suits you.
What the research says about exercise and knee pain
For knee osteoarthritis, avoiding exercise is usually not the answer. A Cochrane review of exercise for knee osteoarthritis pooled 54 studies and found that land-based exercise reduced pain and improved physical function and quality of life. With high-quality evidence from 44 trials, pain dropped by the equivalent of about 12 points on a 100-point scale. A few studies did report some increased knee or low back pain from the exercises, and none reported a serious adverse event. In other words, the right exercise helps, and the wrong one for you may not.
A separate review of squat research found that fears about deep squats harming healthy knees were unfounded when technique is sound, and that half squats and quarter squats were not shown to be safer. That review looked at healthy lifters, so it does not tell you what to do if your knees already hurt.
Alternatives to try
Changing the exercise or the range can help. Options include:
- Box squats or sit-to-stands. Sit back onto a box or chair under control, then stand up. You choose the depth by choosing the height.
- Leg press. A machine supports your back and guides the movement.
- Single-leg press. The same idea, one leg at a time.
- Glute bridges. You lie on your back and lift your hips, which works your glutes and hamstrings with little knee bend.
These are practical suggestions many people find easier on their knees. They are not exercises the research proves are better for a painful knee, so judge by how your own knees feel.
Where Train4Joy fits
Train4Joy's Safety Check asks about joint issues, including knees, and an exercise that would load a flagged joint shows a caution note. You can swap any exercise for an alternative. If you say an exercise caused pain, that swap stays in place for future sessions and the app stops suggesting more weight on it. Box squats, leg press, and single-leg press are among the squat alternatives it offers. Train4Joy is built to help you stay capable, not to treat a medical condition. See how the safety check works.
Ready to try it?
Free to start. Train4Joy is in public beta in the US.